FORMER England international and football pundit Eni Aluko has sparked significant debate after a wide ranging appearance on talkSPORT, where she addressed issues ranging from media scrutiny to governance in women’s football.
Speaking on the station’s breakfast show, Aluko responded to recent criticism aimed at her punditry and public profile, insisting that former players in the women’s game must be allowed space to challenge established structures without being “dismissed or personalised”.
“There’s still an expectation that women in football should be grateful rather than critical,” Aluko said. “If we want the game to keep growing, we need honest conversations even when they’re uncomfortable.”
Her comments quickly gained traction across social media, with supporters praising her for speaking candidly about the pressures faced by female pundits, while others accused her of inflaming division within the sport. Several current and former professionals weighed in throughout the day, highlighting the continued tension between progress and perception in the women’s game.
Aluko also turned her attention to governance, questioning whether decision makers are moving quickly enough to protect players and sustain growth in the Women’s Super League. She suggested that commercial expansion must be matched with stronger safeguarding and clearer leadership.
“The product is improving every season,” she said. “But growth without structure can leave players exposed. We can’t afford to repeat mistakes we’ve seen elsewhere in football.”
The former Chelsea and Juventus forward also reacted to England’s recent international performances, backing head coach Sarina Wiegman to manage expectations ahead of a crucial year. Aluko warned that increased scrutiny is an inevitable consequence of success.
“When you win, standards rise — and that’s a good thing,” she added. “But the analysis has to stay fair and informed.”
TalkSPORT later defended the discussion, saying the station aims to host open debate on all aspects of football. The interview has since been clipped and shared widely, underlining Aluko’s continued influence as one of the most prominent voices in the women’s game.
As women’s football continues to attract larger audiences and greater commercial interest, Aluko’s appearance has once again highlighted the evolving role of former players in shaping the sport’s future — both on and off the pitch.
